Coal Region Killers: Conrad Whyne

Conrad Whyne (from findagrave.com)

February of 1908 was bitterly cold throughout Pennsylvania. Late January and the first half of February brought a severe cold wave through the Coal Region, with several days of sub-zero temperatures and a handful of snowstorms in between. In Mount Carmel, even the numerous bars and taverns, normally crowded on dark winter evenings, were silent and empty. Only the most unapologetic drunkards were out and about. Forty-four year old Conrad Whyne was one of them.

Born in nearby Lavelle in 1863, Whyne had lived most of his adult life in Mount Carmel before moving his wife and eight children to a dilapidated shanty in the woods just west of Locust Gap. Those who knew him in Mount Carmel described him as an inveterate drinker and a notorious nuisance. By 1908, the older of his eight living children (two had died at a young age) had moved out of the house, including his oldest son, John, a 21-year-old coal miner who lived in Locust Gap with his wife, Sallie, and their two young children, Mabel and John, Junior.

On Sunday, February 16, Conrad Whyne, armed with a bottle of whiskey he had brought from home, braved the bitter cold and walked three miles to Mount Carmel, where he stopped at the home of Angelo Barto, secretary of the Liberty Benevolent Society, to pay his membership dues. He then had dinner with the family of a friend, Joe Leinzel, and the two men drank a pint of whiskey which Leinzel had provided.

But the bottle was soon empty and Conrad and Leinzel were still "thirsty", so after dinner the two men roamed the streets, asking everyone they encountered where they could find a drink. Being that it was the Sabbath-- and the coldest February in recent memory-- there weren't many places to obtain liquor that day. But alcoholics can be quite crafty; the two friends continued to ask around until they were directed to a saloon near Beaverdale that happened to be open, in violation of the state's "blue laws". The men drank all afternoon, and when night fell they parted ways at the Beaverdale Cemetery.

Oak Street, Mount Carmel, as it appeared in the early 1900s.

Conrad returned home and found that his wife and children weren't there, so he roamed through Locust Gap looking for them. He stopped at the home of his son John's mother-in-law, Mrs. Sarah Long, asking if his wife was there. Sarah was a widow, her husband having passed away less than two years earlier, and at some point during their conversation the drunken visitor told the widow that he was going to go home and kill his wife. Conrad stormed out of Mrs. Long's house into the frosty night and headed toward home, where he got into a heated quarrel with his wife. 

After Conrad left her home, Mrs. Long ran to the home of her daughter and son-in-law and spread the alarm. Conrad's 18-year-son, Charles, and his 17-year-old daughter, Emma, were at the house when Mrs. Long arrived. As for John, he was in bed asleep.

Because he was Conrad's oldest son, John, for most of his life, had been the peacemaker between his parents during their frequent squabbles. Though it was late, he grabbed his coat and departed for his parents' house, with his young wife following closely behind. They were followed by Charles and Emily, who were also concerned about their mother's safety. Though John walked as fast as he could, the road was icy and treacherous, and the path through the woods was crusted with snow. By the time he arrived at his father's home it was past ten o'clock and his parents were upstairs in the bedroom, getting ready to retire for the evening.

The sound of John entering the home must've enraged his father, because Conrad met him at the top of the stairs with a drawn revolver. John lunged for the weapon and wrestled it out of his father's hand, then hurled it out of a window. Drunk on whiskey and rage, Conrad advanced upon his son, who escaped his clutch by jumping out of the window, landing safely on the snowy ground a few feet below. He then went around to the front door and  attempted to enter the house again, determined to prevent his father from harming his beloved mother. But John was unaware that his father had raced downstairs to grab a double-barreled shotgun. As soon as John threw open the door, Conrad leveled the gun at his son and was about to pull the trigger when Mrs. Whyne slapped at the barrel of the shotgun, causing the charge to strike the ceiling.

Conrad Whyne was now raving like a madman. He savagely knocked down his wife and once again leveled the barrel of the shotgun at his firstborn child. The full charge of #7 birdshot entered the young man's chest at close range, just above the heart, tearing a gaping hole in his body and causing instant death. By this time, his wife had just arrived at the house, and she sank to her knees in grief before fainting by her dead husband's side.

John Whyne (from findagrave.com)

Neighbors Arrive at the Scene

Huey Harvey and Bill Berger, neighbors who had heard the shotgun blasts, raced to the scene of the tragedy. Upon seeing John Whyne dead on the floor and observing Conrad's drunken condition, Harvey confiscated a revolver from the home and then telephoned Chief of Police Abe Morgan in Mount Carmel. 

Morgan, accompanied by Constable David McDonald, set out for the Whyne residence around midnight-- only to run into the man they were out to arrest. Conrad, as it turned out, was walking to Mount Carmel to turn himself in. He was taken into custody without resistance and lodged in the borough jail on Oak Street. He was brought before Justice of the Peace Jacob Reed and formally charged with murder before being taken to Sunbury on the 4:12 morning train and held at the Northumberland County jail. Reed, who was also the acting deputy coroner due to the illness of County Coroner George Dreher, held an inquest later that day and the coroner's jury, comprised of Dr. P.J. Faughman, B.F. Cannon, Isaac March, William Dailey, John Boylan and John Dolan, rendered a verdict declaring that John Whyne came to his death from a gunshot wound inflicted by his father.


A Community Outraged

By the time the sun rose bright over the coal region, word of the murder had spread far and wide. From Centralia to Shamokin, Marion Heights to Trevorton and Ranshaw to Wilburton, the tragic death of John Whyne was the leading topic of conversation. That morning, Conrad Whyne retained the services of defense attorney Thomas Burke, through whom he had issued a statement declaring that he remembered absolutely nothing of the incident; that he was "blind drunk" when the crime was committed. This statement did not earn the killer any sympathy. On the contrary, locals not only wanted to see Conrad hang, but also the person or persons who sold him liquor on that fateful Sunday. One of the local papers, the Mount Carmel Item, wrote that "the seller of the grog should be strung up along with him."

On Friday, February 21, John Whyne was laid to rest at Mount Carmel Cemetery. A large number of friends attended the service. The following Monday, Conrad Whyne was brought back to Mount Carmel by policeman John Cannon for a preliminary hearing before Justice of the Peace Reed. At the train station, he was met by his children, who asked their father why he did what he did, but Conrad was to ashamed to speak; he merely hung his head and walked by without a word. Even at the magistrate's office he did not speak to his family. With an expression of grief etched into his face, he paced the floor, the occasional tear rolling down his cheek.

A hotel in Locust Gap, date unknown

The Preliminary Hearing

At the hearing, after District Attorney Deibler laid out the charge, Conrad was asked for his plea. "Not guilty," he responded. The first witness called was Conrad's 12-year-old son, Aaron, but he was excused. Emma, Conrad's 17-year-old daughter, testified that she had been on her way home when, on the bridge about thirty yards from the Whyne home, she heard two gunshots. She ran toward the house, encountering her mother, who was weeping. Inside the house, she found her father kneeling helplessly over the body of her brother. "Oh my God, Emma," he cried. "Forgive me. Forgive me. I shot him dead."

During cross-examination, Emma testified that her father was drunk at the time, and her story was corroborated under oath by her brother Charles, who testified that he had found the shotgun outside in the yard after the shooting, and had smashed it beyond repair so that it could cause no more trouble. Next to testify was John's widow, Sallie, who explained that Conrad never liked John very much, and that she had once seen him draw a revolver and point it at her husband. The defense offered no testimony, and Justice of the Peace Reed committed the defendant to the county prison without bail.

Mrs. Sarah Long, the victim's mother-in-law.
 

Another Death in the Family

Most folks born and raised in the coal region are proud of their heritage, and they have every reason to be. Their ancestors, many of whom had arrived from Europe with nothing more than a dream, pulled deep from the earth the black diamonds which not only powered America, but transformed the country into a world power. Two world wars could not have been fought and won without anthracite coal, which was used extensively in military production. The owners of the mines became millionaires, but, for the miners, the rewards for their back-breaking and dangerous labor were renting a company house, shopping at the company store, and surviving a shift to see another day.

One man whose luck happened to run out two days after Conrad Whyne's preliminary hearing was David Wolfgang, who was the brother of Conrad's wife, Mary. On February 25, Wolfgang met a terrible death after being literally blown to pieces at the Locust Spring Colliery at Locust Gap when a spark from his lamp caused a powder keg to explode. In a span of just nine days, Mary Ann Whyne endured the double tragedy of the death of her younger brother and the murder of her firstborn child.

Sadly, Mary would outlive all but three of her children. Two boys, Harry and William, died before the age of four. Another son, Thomas, died at the age of 22 after being mangled by a train near Locust Gap. Emma died of uremia just four years later, in 1918, at the age of 27. Charles died in 1938, at the age of 38, after a lengthy illness.


Hunting Down the Grog Sellers

Because Pennsylvania's long-standing ban of Sunday liquor sales (which wasn't lifted until 1971), authorities were determined to find out where Conrad Whyne had obtained liquor on Sunday, February 16. The names of two saloonkeepers came out during testimony at the preliminary hearing, but were withheld from the public. When the facts were confirmed by the county detective, they were laid out before Judge Savidge in Sunbury, who ordered that the two men not only close their establishments permanently and immediately, but to sell their properties within two weeks. Many applauded this ruling, though some questioned whether the court had the authority to issue such a demand. Ultimately, the two proprietors acquiesced.


The Trial of Conrad Whyne

The trial for the murder of John Whyne opened September 28, 1908, with Judge Savidge presiding. Attorneys Thomas N. Burke and Francis E. Bucher represented the defendant. It was a remarkable year for crime in the coal region; Conrad Whyne was one of four men occupying "murderer's row" at Northumberland County Prison. The others were Henry Fisher, who murdered his housekeeper, Sarah Klinger, in Shamokin; Stanny Marcavage, who murdered an elderly cobbler in Coal Township, and Daniel Thompson, who fatally stabbed his uncle, Daniel Burch, during a drunken brawl in Mount Carmel.

There were no surprises or earth-shattering revelations during the one-day trial, as the facts weren't in dispute. Whyne had been too drunk to remember anything about the murder, and his wife and children repeated the same version of events as they had done at the preliminary hearing. After deliberating for two hours, the jury returned its verdict, finding Conrad Whyne guilty of murder in the second degree.

 

The Sentencing and Aftermath

Conrad's attorneys immediately sought a new trial for their client, who complained that he shouldn't have been found guilty at all, as he had been too drunk to control his behavior. As a result of the killer's statements, he was excoriated by newspapers across Pennsylvania by reporters who felt Conrad had quite the audacity to demand a retrial, writing that he should be grateful he wasn't found guilty of first degree murder. The Altoona Tribune wrote:

It is singular the criminal is not satisfied. He wants another trial. He says he was so drunk when he killed his son that he didn't know what he was doing... It will be a sorry day for the state when courts begin to excuse crime on account of the drunken condition of the criminal at the time his unlawful deed was perpetrated.

On October 19, 1908, Conrad Whyne received his sentence-- ten years of imprisonment, not in the dreaded Eastern Penitentiary, but at the county jail. Interestingly, on the day one coal region killer received his sentence, the corpse of another was being shipped home for burial. Jacob Gearhart, the Shamokin wife murderer, died at Eastern Penitentiary on October 18 from kidney disease. In a strange twist of fate, he was laid to rest at Mount Carmel Cemetery, the same graveyard where the murdered John Whyne is buried.

The historic Northumberland County Prison

It wasn't long before Conrad was involved in another sensational story, when he was spotted on the streets of Sunbury, running errands for jail officials. Investigation into the matter revealed that the the killer, who had been sentenced by Judge Savidge to hard labor during his term of confinement, had been granted special privileges-- including being allowed to go fishing. The Mount Carmel Daily News put the story on its front page, blasting county officials for permitting the convicted killer to live "a life of ease and luxury" behind bars.

Conrad Whyne was paroled in August of 1911, having spent a grand total of three years and five months in jail for the brutal murder of his own son, after being able to convince the court that his health was failing and that his time on earth would soon be over. He didn't pass away for 16 more years, and his death had nothing to do with failing health; he was struck and killed by a car while crossing West Third Street in Mount Carmel in September of 1927.

Comments